Many
children dislike using public toilets, which are often not the nicest of
environments. A lot of parents will be
able to tell stories of their children trying, and sometimes failing, to hang
on until they get home when they need a wee, which can result in wet pants or
an emergency wee behind a bush, against a wall, down a drain or beside the car. They may be even more reluctant to do a poo
on an unfamiliar toilet.
![]() |
| Many children prefer using the toilet at home to using public toilets. This was certainly the case with me when it came to doing a poo. (c) |
In my
case I had no problems using public toilets when I needed a wee. Indeed, unlike many little boys, I did not
regard the outside world as my personal urinal and would have to be really
desperate before I would consent to urinating al fresco. But it was a different story when I was away
from home and needed a poo. Although I
was willing to park my bottom on a public toilet when I was very young, as I
got older it became a complete no-no for me.
I think this
probably came from my early experiences of using the Ladies as a little boy,
with my Mum or older sister standing outside the cubicle urging me to hurry
up. I never liked to rush when sitting
on the toilet so I stopped asking to be taken in the first place and simply
withheld my poo in a similar way to what I did at home. Naturally, this resulted in a lot of
accidents, either on the trip itself, necessitating an embarrassing clean up,
or after returning home. After a while
avoiding the toilet and withholding when on day trips and holidays became so
common for me that I did it without even thinking about it, like it was an
automatic response. Even my mother’s
expressed displeasure at having to change my pants on days out failed to
change my behaviour.
After the age of 8 most of my accidents occurred
away from home. Avoiding public toilets
when I wanted a poo had become so deeply ingrained in me that it was even
harder to break the habit than withholding at home had been. However, my accidents on trips decreased in
frequency over time and eventually became very rare, helped by the fact I
was now old enough to use the Gents by myself.
![]() |
| Aged 5, at Skegness with Paddington Bear. Days out were fun, but I often had an accident in my pants. |
One trip that sticks in my mind was when I was 10
years old and my mother took my sister and me away for the weekend to a wedding
in Humberside. Before we went my mother
told me how she was packing spare underwear ‘in case you have an accident.’ It was one of the few occasions when I can
recall her referring to my soiling problem while I was clean.
At the disco on the evening of the wedding I needed
a poo and shortly afterward felt the need to wee as well. Amazingly, the Gents contained only one
toilet, and two men who also needed to answer the call of nature came with
me. As a child, I was allowed to go
first. I unzipped my trousers and emptied my
bladder. I hesitated for a second but
then, despite the fact that these two men were standing outside the cubicle
waiting, I pulled down my trousers and pants and sat on the toilet to do my poo
and stayed there until I was happy I had finished.
I don’t know what gave me the confidence to poo in
public toilets in such circumstances that weekend. It might have been wanting to avoid the
embarrassment of soiling myself at the age of 10 in front of so many people, or
a determination that the spare pants my mother had packed would not be
needed. But looking back I feel it was a
breakthrough. However, I was still not completely free of accidents.


would your mum ever catch u witholding
ReplyDeleteNo, I don't think she even knew that I was withholding. I think she thought that I just wasn't using the toilet and pooing in my pants instead.
Deletewhat age would you say a child who has problems using the toilet versus a averge child should wipe there own bum
ReplyDeleteI do not know if there is any difference. Children seem to develop this skill at a variety of different ages, regardless of whether they have other toilet issues or not.
Deletei clean my 10 year old sons bum. he wants me to do it. if i dont he makes skid marks in his underwear. is this normal
ReplyDeleteI would say that most 10 year olds wipe their own bottoms, but it's not unusual for them to have skid marks in their underwear.
Deletewould u ever soil yourself twice or more a day?
ReplyDeleteI can't remember ever doing so, but I know that a lot of children who have encopresis have multiple accidents in a day.
Deletehow often would your mum pack spare pants on a trip out?
ReplyDeletealso i know this is a weird one but when but would u ever put your hands down your pants when u had an accident. i say this because when i discover my boy has had an accident i find bit of poo on his fingers. this is because he puts his hands down there to check if there is poo in his bum and wash his hands after. i caught him doing it once. would u ever do this?
My mother didn't usually tell me if she had packed spare pants in case I had an accident on a trip out.
DeleteI can vaguely recall a small number of occasions when I put my hands in my pants to see if I had soiled them. I would remove them as soon as they touched any poo.
would u do this as an older child or as a toddler?
DeleteNot as a toddler, it was definitely when I was older.
DeleteEven As an adult, I find that i still withold my poop. I will always avoid it. I can see why i had so many problems as a kid. This behavior never really seems to leave me. However, as an adult, I don't soil myself.
ReplyDeleteAs an adult I am the opposite to what I was a child. If I need to poo, then I am willing to use any toilet to do so, including ones which aren't too pleasant. There is no way that I am going back to withholding and risking my childhood problems returning.
DeleteHi Jorden, like you, even as an adult I still withhold, especially when there are people I know or in a place where going to the toilet is going to draw attention. It’s not a problem now but it was for quite a while after I left school. I was good at not being discovered but not always and that led to some embarrassing situations.
ReplyDeleteI cannot remember whether I had messed my pants shortly before the wedding trip, or whether I soiled myself again between this time and my final accident, although I think it's likely that I did, I can't imagine that I managed to stay clean on every trip for a whole year.
ReplyDeleteThe number of times I had pooed my pants on trips in the past would have been the reason that my mother had judged that there was a high probability that I would need changing at some point during the weekend. I don't think her telling me about the spare pants was intended to encourage me to use the toilet so I wouldn't need them, but that was probably the effect that it had. Maybe she told me because if I did have an accident, she wanted me to tell her so she could change my pants straight away, rather than keep quiet and be stinky for ages around a large number of family and friends, one of whom would probably eventually tell her that I smelled of poo, which would have been embarrassing for all concerned. However, I'm sure I wouldn't have told my mother that I had pooed myself, and would have put off the humiliating clean-up for as long as possible.
I didn't tell my mother that I had done a poo in the toilet, and I didn't get praised for staying clean that weekend. As you say, feedback such as, 'Congratulations, you didn't poo your pants,' or even, 'Well done for using the toilet,' would have been embarrassing for me as a 10 year old, although I think some praise for pooing in the toilet when I was younger would have been encouraging.
I think positive reinforcement goes a lot further in encouraging right behavior than scolding after a failure. In your case the scolding seems to have made the situation worse, not only making you afraid to tell your mother when you had an accident, but perhaps even creating the problem of not wanting to think about using the toilet when you really needed it. Can you think of any encouraging things a parent could say or do that wouldn’t be embarrassing or come off as patronizing? And, purely speculative, do you think in your case any of this might have helped you to solve the problem sooner than age eleven? At the very least, I think focusing on accomplishments over failures would help to boost an unfortunate child’s poor self image.
ReplyDeleteI would say a simple "Well done!" after doing a poo in the toilet, with a smile and possibly an occasional cuddle, would have helped me, as using the toilet was not an automatic response for me when I felt the need to poo and I'd had to fight the instinct to withhold. This would have made a welcome contrast to being scolded for soiling myself and may well have helped me to overcome my withholding habit sooner.
ReplyDeleteBut I think my mother was of the opinion that a 5/6/7/8/9/10/11 year old shouldn't be praised for doing something which a child of that age should be expected to do as a matter of course anyway. In fairness, she was probably as unaware as I was at the time that there were many other children well past potty training age who still had problems using the toilet and messed their pants, many of them fair more frequently than me.